Rent and Manage Your Home

Recently, one of our owners lost their investment property (that we were managing) to foreclosure.  In the new day we currently live in, this change in ownership (from individual to bank) will mean little to the tenant.  Unlike just two years ago, the banks are honoring leases under the Protecting Tenants In Foreclosure law passed in 2009. 

Where a bank is not traditionally handling property management, they have had to go out and find companies to handle this task for them.  Unfortunately, the banks have chosen to handle tenants and management the same way they handle property services…wholesale.  The banks are hiring large companies to serve the property management function.  These “wholesalers” are providing nothing more than a back room and a local person with little or no property management experience.  Without going into too much more depth as to the ramifications of this approach, having an inexperienced field person working the transition of a property to a new manager created some issues when it came to the handling of the security deposit.

This issue is relevant to both a tenant and owner.  We hold every dollar of deposits in state regulated escrow accounts.  This money belongs to the tenant unless they violate their lease in a way that creates a need to reimburse the owner.  So, just because Wells Fargo is knocking at the door demanding we hand over the security deposit, we don’t just write a check.

Likewise, if you, as an owner, are transferring property managers, we expect all parties to handle their fiduciary responsibilities as to the security deposit in a manner that honors the tenant’s interests.  Tenants have the right to be made aware that a property manager is changing.  The correct way to handle a change in managers is to:

Utilize a letter explaining the transition.  This letter should be generated by the new property manager and ideally also signed by the owner and tenant.

Issue a check for the security deposit to both the tenant and the new property manager. 

We will usually take this check to the tenant for endorsement with the letter.  In this way we are able to introduce ourselves as the new manager, answer any questions, and have a written record of receipt of the transfer letter and endorsement of the security deposit funds into our escrow account.

Needless to say, the field person hired by the wholesale property management company hired by the bank had no connection to any procedures like this.  Basically, stating that they had the full power of the US government supporting their actions, they insisted that we hand over our lease and write them a check for the security deposit.  The resulting conflict took a few days and a call with the wholesale property manager.  We gave them a check made payable to the wholesale manager and the tenant.  I wonder what happened after that?